The Great Pumpkin Debate

From our wedding. Photo by Tinywater ©

Those that know me know just how much I LOVE Halloween.Tom and I even got married on Halloween in the ultimate DIY labor of love. Half of the tower is packed with Halloween decor, most of it being the classy Martha-Stewart-esque type of decor. No plastic crap for us.

So it was kind of a surprise when last year I decided to forgo growing pumpkins. I didn’t want to deal with the whole saving seeds thing between pumpkins and zucchini (both the same species – C. pepo). I also decided to not “waste” space on non-edibles. Pumpkins – the jack-o-lantern types – are edible, but they are bland, watery and stringy. We just don’t eat them. Of course when I made that decision Halloween and the crisp fall, my favorite time of year, was well behind us. I think my judgment was clouded because now I’m sitting here now pissed that I didn’t grow any pumpkins.

Granted I did grow some Musquee d’ Provence squash that are otherwise known as “Fairytale Pumpkins” and they are gorgeous but they just aren’t the same. They aren’t easily carved and I would prefer not to waste them because they are good eating. But they are big squash and I find that around here, big squash go uneaten because we never want to cook a whole one all at once. We generally don’t want to eat squash two days in a row either. The other squash we’re growing this year (rather unsuccessfully) is Marina di Chioggia, also known as a Sea Pumpkin (notice a theme here?). It’s a type of turban, big, green and warty. It has the most amazing flavor I’ve ever had in a squash. But when we are able to grow them they don’t make very good substitutes for pumpkins.

I’ve spent years growing pumpkins. Most years were pretty disappointing. But I continued to try to grow them. I remember my very first pumpkin that I was able to produce and I was so excited about it. The one pumpkin plant in the picture gave us 4 of these monsters – each weighing over 50lbs with the largest topping out at 75lbs. These weren’t a giant pumpkin variety. They were Howden’s – the typical jack-o-lantern – grown with a good helping of chicken manure. if you couldn’t tell, I’m very proud of these. So is Squeek.

This is what I want to start growing again. Big orange pumpkins. So this coming year I’m going back to growing pumpkins and also some other squash such as Trombocino, Acorn, Spaghetti, Marina di Chioggia, and probably some other random ones (I’m rather enamored with Iran squash which Baker Creek just started carrying seeds for).


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


  1. Dragonista says:

    I don’t carve my pumpkins until the day before Halloween and then the day after, I cut them up, peel with a peeler and make soup (boil/steam and blend away)! I leave it plain and freeze the majority of it. On cold winter days, I pop it into the microwave and add spices (nutmeg, cinnamon, _or_ even oregano), sour cream or whatever my mood leads me to add :)– So you don’t have to have the typical baked squash for dinner two nights in a row… and hot soup on a cold rainy/snowy day sure is awesome! It’s also become a must have at Thanksgiving.

  2. Wow that Iran squash almost looks tie-dyed! Our growing space (thanks the terrain here) is pretty tight, so I completely understand your initial decision not to grow something as sprawling as pumpkins, especially if it’s not food. Well, food for you anyway. We don’t grow the carving pumpkins for that reason, although we do grow the sweet pie-types. I have considered taking a few of them and just etching a pattern into the skin as they, just for fun. A little extra justification for growing the jack-o-lantern types, even if you don’t eat them, is your turkeys will. It took ours a couple of days to get over their fear of the giant orange balls, but once they figured them out, now they just demolish them, and the chickens enjoy them too. Alternatively, you could grow Boston Marrow. They’re plenty huge enough to carve, and we used them all through the winter last year. Not the most flavorful, but really not bad, and they store great!

  3. Well, it was a less than pleasant growing season down here in Pittsburg, due to illness (doing way better now, though my strength is wobbly), so I won’t have any home-grown squashes other than my three surviving butternuts.
    I did however discover the Musquee d’Provence pumpkins at the local Mi Pueblo market last winter, and boy they make awesome soup w/ roasted garlic. And they store well, and freeze well, and they do well in Thai curry.
    It’s hard though, buying these. I had all these plans for growing Tromboncino and some pie variety pumpkins, and stuff went tits up before we could even sprout and transplant into the beds. The seeds came from Fedco so I’m not worried about ‘em going south too quickly.


  1. [...] pumpkin is coming back! We’ll be growing Howden pumpkins again but I’m also going to be adding Winter Luxury [...]

Join the Discussion

Comment Policy: We love a lively discussion but we reserve the right to delete comments. In other words, don't be a jerk


+ four = 7